Home   |   Sitemap   |   PM   |   Distributors' Corner   |   Contact
  Anton Paar GmbH  
search
   
User: login help
Key:
login
register
   
Sample Preparation
 
  Customer portraits
  Application reports
  Links
A A
  Images
   
  Theory Microwave Technology
 
Open digestion vs. closed digestion
Enlarge image
    

Comparison: Open and closed decomposition

 

Open
Digestion

 

Samples and reagents are heated on a hotplate, in a sand bath or in a microwave-heated system. The sample and reagents are in open vessels made of glass, quartz, glassy carbon or PTFE. The gas vapors which are produced are either extracted or caught by a reflux condenser and returned to the reaction mixture.

The maximum reaction temperature is dictated by the boiling point of the acid mixture at ambient pressure.

Sample amount 0.5 to 10 g
Reagent consumption 10 to 100 mL
Digestion duration 2 to 10 h
 

Use

 
  • Inhomogenous samples
  • Easy to dissolve samples
  • High analyte concentration
  • In combination with flame AAS
 

Benefits

 
  • Simple and reasonably priced equipment
  • Easy to use
  • High sample throughput, very good for inhomogeneous samples
  • Any reaction gases can evaporate unhindered (no build-up of pressure)
 

Dis-advantages

 
  • Maximum temperature is limited to the boiling point of the reagent mixture; poor decomposition quality
  • Long decomposition time
  • Use of H2SO4 to increase the temperature of the mixture
  • Difficult to produce pure sulfuric acid
  • Interferes with many subsequent analysis methods due to its high viscosity and forms sulfates with low solubility when mixed with many metals (e.g. Cd, Pb, etc.), which leads to values which are lower than the actual values
  • High consumption of reagents, high blank values
  • Evaporated reagents must be refilled during the decomposition
  • Possible contamination from reagents and the environment
  • Produces corrosive air in the laboratory
  • Loss of volatile elements
    Hg (elemental)
    As, B, Cr, Ge, Pb, Sn, Te, Ti, Zn, Zr (as halogen compounds)
    Os, Rh, Ru (under oxidative conditions)
    Se, Te (under reductive conditions) 
  • Large vessels (i.e. 250 ml) with large surfaces, adsorption effects and loss of analytes
  • Time-consuming cleaning required after decomposition
 

Closed
Digestion

 

Samples and reagents are heated in closed pressure vessels made of fluoroplastics (PFA, PTFE, PTFE-TFM) or quartz. The pressure vessels can be heated conventionally (autoclave, heating block) or using microwave technology. The reaction is controlled via temperature and pressure sensors.

The maximum reaction temperature depends on the thermal stability and pressure stability of the vessel material used.

Sample amount 0.1 to 1 g (organic sample matrix)
0.5 to 5 g (inorganic sample matrix)
Reagent consumption 2 to 10 mL
Digestion duration 0.2 to 1 h

 

Use

 
  • All materials
  • Matrices which are difficult to dissolve
  • For all measuring methods (spectrometry, voltammetry)
     
 

Benefits

 
  • High temperatures (up to 300°C depending on the instrument and vessel type)
  • High pressures (up to 80 bar depending on the instrument and vessel type)
  • Complete decomposition results due to the high temperatures and pressures
  • Simple acid mixtures; HNO3 is sufficient for organic samples
  • H2SO4 or HClO4 are not required
  • Low reagent volumes, reduction of blank values and reagent costs
  • Short reaction times
  • No loss of volatile elements
  • Does not lead to corrosive air in the laboratory
  • Small vessels and inert materials, extremely low adsorption effects
 

Dis-
advantages

 
  • Higher purchase cost
  • Limited sample weight; higher weights produce larger amounts of reaction gases which remain in the vessels and lead to pressure which must be controlled
 
    
Send this pagePrint this pageAdd this page to your favorites
   Advanced search   |   Glossary   |   Disclaimer   |   Help   |   Legal Notice © Anton Paar 2007